श्रद्धात्रयविभागयोगः
Śraddhātraya Vibhāga Yoga — The Yoga of the Division of Threefold Faith
Arjuna opens by asking about the status of those who sacrifice with faith but outside scriptural ordinance, and Krishna answers by sidestepping the binary entirely: faith itself is threefold by nature (sattvic, rajasic, tamasic), and this same guna-typology is then applied systematically across objects of worship, food, sacrifice, austerity, and gift-giving — directly paralleling the guna framework of Chapter 14 and previewing the closing typology of Chapter 18. The chapter closes with an exposition of the "Om Tat Sat" three-syllable formula as the threefold name of Brahman used to consecrate ritual acts, ending on the declaration that anything done without faith (shraddha) is "Asat" — null and void, here or hereafter.
About this chapter
Chapter 16 ended by making scripture the standard for what to do. Arjuna’s question opens chapter 17: what about the sincere person who worships without it — “endowed with faith” but outside the letter of the ordinance (BG 17.1)? Krishna answers not by ruling them in or out, but by sorting their faith — and everything it produces — by guṇa.
Faith is what you are
Faith, Krishna says, is svabhāva-jā — “born of one’s own nature” (BG 17.2), so it comes in three kinds. The key line is BG 17.3: “a person is made of faith; as their faith is, so are they.” Faith is not an opinion one holds but the substance one is — which is why sorting it by guṇa is really sorting people, and the same act done by three people can carry three colours.
The threefold grid
The rest of the chapter runs one fivefold list — worship, food, sacrifice, austerity, gift — three ways each. The figure below is that grid. Some highlights: sāttvic food is defined by its effect (life, health, cheer), tāmasic food by decay (stale, putrid, a day old, already partly eaten). A sāttvic sacrifice is done “because it ought to be offered,” with no craving for the fruit (BG 17.11); a rājasic one for the result and the good showing (BG 17.12); a tāmasic one is “devoid of faith” (BG 17.13). Austerity is first split by faculty — body, speech, mind (BG 17.14–BG 17.16) — then by guṇa. And the clearest test of a sāttvic gift is anupakāriṇe — given to someone who cannot repay (BG 17.20).
Oṃ Tat Sat
The close (BG 17.23–BG 17.28) gives the threefold name of Brahman — Oṃ Tat Sat — as a way to consecrate an act: Oṃ opens it, Tat marks the renunciation of its fruit, Sat names steadfastness and any action “done for That.” An act outside the letter of scripture can still be aligned with the absolute by the intention these syllables mark. And the last word: whatever is done “without faith” is Asat, “and it avails nothing, here or hereafter” (BG 17.28).
How the chapter moves
- v1–6Faith is what you are — The faith of the embodied is threefold, born of one's nature — 'as a person's faith is, so are they.' The sāttvic worship the gods, the rājasic nature-spirits, the tāmasic the dead. Scriptureless, torturing austerity is demonic.
- v7–13Food, and sacrifice, three ways — Sāttvic food sustains (life, health, cheer); rājasic inflames (extremes of taste, then pain); tāmasic decays. Sāttvic sacrifice for its own sake; rājasic for result and display; tāmasic devoid of faith.
- v14–19Austerity — by faculty, then by guṇa — Body: reverence, purity, non-violence. Speech: true, kind, helpful, unupsetting. Mind: serenity, silence, pure intent. Sāttvic when done with faith and no craving; rājasic for show; tāmasic from delusion or to harm.
- v20–22Giving, three ways — Sāttvic: 'because it should be given,' to one who cannot repay, in the right place, time, and to a worthy person. Rājasic: for a return, grudgingly. Tāmasic: wrong place and time, unworthy recipient, with contempt.
- v23–28Oṃ Tat Sat — The threefold name of Brahman consecrates an act — Oṃ opens it, Tat marks renouncing the fruit, Sat names steadfastness. Whatever is done without faith is Asat, and avails nothing here or hereafter.
| Worship of…BG 17.4 | Food preferredBG 17.8 | SacrificeBG 17.11 | AusterityBG 17.17 | GiftBG 17.20 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sāttvic — clarity | the gods (devān) | juicy, smooth, sustaining — increasing life, vigour, health, joy (17.8) | by the rule, seeking no fruit — 'it ought to be offered' (17.11) | the threefold discipline done with supreme faith, seeking no fruit (17.17) | 'because it should be given,' to one who cannot repay, right place/time/person (17.20) |
| Rājasic — passion | yakṣas and rākṣasas | bitter, sour, salty, very hot, pungent, burning — bringing pain, grief, sickness (17.9) | aimed at the fruit, or for display (17.12) | for honour, respect, and show — unsteady, short-lived (17.18) | grudgingly, for a return, or with an eye on the merit (17.21) |
| Tāmasic — inertia | the departed (pretas) and hosts of spirits | stale, tasteless, putrid, a day old, leftover, unclean (17.10) | against the rule — no food, no mantra, no gift, devoid of faith (17.13) | from a deluded fixation, with self-torture, or to harm another (17.19) | wrong place and time, to unworthy persons, without respect, with contempt (17.22) |
Faith conforms to one's nature — 'a person is made of faith; as their faith, so are they' (17.3). The same act takes a different colour depending on the faith behind it.
Concept map for this chapter
Those that sacrifice full of faith, but casting aside the ordinances of the Scriptures, what is verily their condition, O Krishna? Is it one of Purity, Passion, or Darkness?
Threefold is by nature the inborn faith of the embodied—pure, passionate, and dark. Hear thou of these.
The faith of each is shaped to his own nature, O Bhârata. The man consists of his faith; that which his faith is, he is even that.
Pure men worship the Gods; the passionate the gnomes and giants; the others, the dark folk, worship ghosts and troops of nature-spirits.
The men who perform severe austerities, unenjoined by the Scriptures, wedded to vanity and egoism, impelled by the force of their desires and passions,
Unintelligent, tormenting the aggregated elements forming the body, and Me also, seated in the inner body, know these demoniacal in their resolves.
The food also which is dear to each is threefold, as also sacrifice, austerity and almsgiving. Hear thou the distinction of these.
The foods that augment vitality, energy, vigour, health, joy and cheerfulness, delicious, bland, substantial and agreeable, are dear to the pure.
The passionate desire foods that are bitter, sour, saline, over-hot, pungent, dry and burning and which produce pain, grief and sickness.
That which is stale and flat, putrid and corrupt, leavings also and unclean, is the food dear to the dark.
The sacrifice which is offered by men without desire for fruit, as enjoined by the ordinances, under the firm belief that sacrifice is a duty, that is pure.
The sacrifice offered with a view verily to fruit, and also indeed for self-glorification, O best of the Bhâratas; know thou that to be of passion.
The sacrifice contrary to the ordinances, without distributing food, devoid of words of power and without gifts, empty of faith, is said to be of darkness.
Worship given to the Gods, to the twice-born, to the teachers and to the wise, purity, straightforwardness, continence and harmlessness, are called the austerity of the body.
Speech causing no annoyance, truthful, pleasant and beneficial, the practice of the study of the Scriptures, are called the austerity of speech.
Mental happiness, equilibrium, silence, self-control, purity of nature—these are called the austerity of the mind.
This threefold austerity, performed by men with the utmost faith, without desire for fruit, harmonised, is said to be pure.
The austerity which is practised with the object of gaining respect, honour and worship, and for ostentation, is said to be of passion, unstable and fleeting.
That austerity done under a deluded understanding, with self-torture, or with the object of destroying another, that is declared of darkness.
That alms given to one who does nothing in return, believing that a gift ought to be made in a fit place and time to a worthy person, that alms is accounted pure.
That given with a view to receiving in return, or looking for fruit again, or grudgingly, that alms is accounted of passion.
That alms given at unfit place and time, and to unworthy persons, disrespectfully and contemptuously, that is declared of darkness.
"Aum Tat Sat," this has been considered to be the threefold designation of the Eternal. By that were ordained of old Brâhmanas, Vedas and sacrifices.
Therefore with the pronunciation of "Aum" the acts of sacrifice, gift and austerity as laid down in the ordinances are always commenced by the knowers of the Eternal.
With the pronunciation of "Tat" and without aiming at fruit are performed the various acts of sacrifice, austerity and gift, by those desiring liberation.
"Sat" is used in the sense of reality and goodness; likewise, O Pârtha, the word "Sat" is used in the sense of a good work.
Steadfastness in sacrifice, austerity and gift is also called "Sat", and action for the sake of the Supreme is also named "Sat."
Whatsoever is wrought without faith, oblation, gift, austerity, or other deed, "Asat" it is called, O Pârtha; it is nought, here or hereafter.